Wednesday, December 3, 2008
3 quick defs/descriptions
king's 2 bodies-one body is spiritual, one is physical; Lear believed he could give up physical body but maintain spiritual; Lear believed spiritual was granted by God
Cleopatra-not presumably good looking; one of martest women in history; probably a virgin before Pompey; very productive writer; fought in own military; did not sleep with lots of men; held off Roman Empire from taking over Egypt longer than anyone else defended their city
Brantley Watson
Amanda Waldo
1D
The Black Friar's Theater
The Tempest and Colonization
I thought it was interesting when Professor Little made the comment in lecture that The Tempest is Shakespeare’s most popular play in some countries, especially those that have experience with colonization. In many ways, events in The Tempest do resemble European colonization. All of the characters who land on the island find it within their rights to claim it and make it their own. Gonzalo is an example of one character who dreams that he can transform the island into what he wants it to be, creating a perfect society nostalgic of the golden age, with Gonzalo as its leader. Prospero, though, is the main allegorical colonizer figure in the play. He thinks he has complete authority over the island, even though Sycorax and Caliban had already been living there prior to his arrival. Prospero immediately turns Caliban into his servant, forcing him to do all of his work on the island. According to Caliban, he was once his “own king” (I.ii.342), but now he is a prisoner. Prospero and Miranda, acting as the colonizers, use very patronizing language toward him and act as though he owes something to them. They feel he should be happy that they found him and supposedly taught him how to be more civilized, particularly by teaching him to speak their own language. While they continue to deny Caliban his freedom throughout the play, Prospero also constantly denies Ariel his freedom. Prospero seems to promise Ariel that he will have his freedom soon, but up until the very end of the play, he withholds Ariel’s freedom, in an assertion of his own control.
Throughout the play, there are many examples of outsiders craving power and feeling they can simply go in and take it. Antonio usurped the dukedom from Prospero, Sebastian plotted to usurp the throne from Alonso, and Prospero usurped freedom from Caliban. These characters in The Tempest all want power and control. As Professor Little suggested, Shakespeare faced his own disillusionment in The Tempest, and he began to reflect on the absolutism he saw in himself as an artist through these characters.
Laura Anderson, 1B
Response: Virtus
"Volumnia is the direct challenger of Virtus. Volumnia is the sole representation of Civitas, order and a feminine connotation. And, without Volumnia, Coriolanus is unable to function. As discussed in class, behind every man there is a great woman. Rome is in a state of uproar because Coriolanus desires this sense of control, order, and masculinity, but he fails at this and is completely held up by the support of his voluptuous Volumnia.In conclusion, Rome displays the virtus but deep down it is simply a hysterical nation in a masculine disguise."
I thought this was really interesting (I'm not sure if Professor Little said this in class or if it was a student conclusion), but if Volumnia is supposed to be the embodiment of Civitas, she must be really bad at it. It's true that she's the one person who is able to prevent Coriolanus from leveling Rome with her maternal influence, but her conversation with Virginia in Act I contradicts the idea of her as civitas personified:
"To a cruel
war I sent him; from whence he returned, his brows
bound with oak. I tell thee, daughter, I sprang not
more in joy at first hearing he was a man-child
than now in first seeing he had proved himself a man." (1.3.I'd cite the lines, but the online version I'm using right now has no line numbers)
Volumnia spends the rest of the scene explaining that men are most glorious and beautiful when bloodied from war, insisting that "Hecuba/When she did suckle Hector, look'd not lovelier/Than Hector's forehead when it spit/forth blood/At Grecian sword, contemning man" (1.3).
Almost every line from Volumia in this scene is of a violent nature, therefore implying that she is at this point the embodiment of virtus, not civitas. Of course, all of her inclinations toward violence appear in speech alone, whereas her actions toward the end of the play betray a side of her perhaps more ruled by civitas. The only reason she becomes less violent, however, is because her own country is threatened; if the defense of Rome were not in question, she would probably still be behind Corialanus, urging him to bash someone's face in.
Volumnia is certainly influencial and multi-dimensional - expressed by even her name alone - but she appears to be driven by virtus, not civitas. Perhaps the tension between her and Coriolanus is similar to the tension between Coriolanus and Audifius: as Professor Little said, both men can't be the pitcher. If Volumnia is in fact an embodiment of virtus, then she is a competitor of Coriolanus who ends up topping. Her show of civitas near the end of the play, then, is perhaps only a facade to momentarily disguise her true masculine nature in a strange sort of reversal of Rome, which is merely a nation of civitas disgused as a nation of virtus.
Vanessa Yeh
Ian Hoch
1B
Miranda's Deaf Ear
As evidenced by the Masque (overly ornate and elaborate stage productions that relied on theatricality), audiences in Shakespeare's time were becoming accustomed to theater as a "visual feast," wherein the entire play is artifice. Shakespeare's possible concern was that viewers interpreted theater merely as stories that could be presented visually, rather than an audio meditation or discussion.
Miranda's deaf ear, then, is a parallel to the deaf ears of Shakespeare's audience, who may have begun to rely on the visial rather than the audio.
Vanessa Yeh
Ian Hoch
1B
Virtus and Civitas in Antony and Cleopatra
Virtus: Manliness in War
Civitas: Civil Society
Rome=Virtus Vs. Egypt=Civitas
The problem with Egypt (Cleopatra) for Caesar is it has too much Civitas.
The problem with Rome (Antony) there is too much Virtus.
When Anthony is caught between Rome and Egypt he has an unbalanced amount of both Virtus and Civitas.
The new Rome (Caesar) wants to balance the two.
Melanie Austin
Aaron Gorelik
Tuesday, December 2, 2008
Coriolanus as a Scapegoat (Pharmakos)
Chris Shelton
Aaron Gorelik
Section 1C