Thursday, October 23, 2008

I am as well acquainted here as I was in our house of profession. One would think it were Mistress Overdone's own house, for here be many of her old c

POM. I am as well acquainted here as I was in our house of profession. One would think it were Mistress Overdone's own house, for here be many of her old customers. First, here's young Master Rash, he's in for a commodity of brown paper and old ginger, ninescore and seventeen pounds, of which he made five marks ready money. Marry, then ginger was not much in request, for the old women were all dead. Then is there here one Master Caper, at the suit of Master Three-pile the mercer, for some four suits of peach-color'd satin, which now peaches him a beggar. Then have we here young Dizzy, and young Master Deep-vow, and Master Copper-spur, and Master Starve-lackey the rapier and dagger man, and young Drop-heir that kill'd lusty Pudding, and Master Forthlight the tilter, and brave Master Shoe-tie the great traveller, and wild Half-can that stabb'd Pots, and I think forty more, all great doers in our trade, and are now 'for the Lord's sake.'

This speech is given by Pompey the Clown during Act IV, scene III of “Measure for Measure.” It occurs shortly after Pompey has switched occupation, converting himself from bawd to undertaker's assistant. In the most literal sense, the passage describes how Pompey is comfortable in his new profession because all the men he saw at the whorehouse as a bawd are present on death row. A closer reading of the passage reveals that this is not merely a list of Pompey's friends, but is also a catalog of the play-world's sexual deviants and their multitude of varying sexual desires. Shakespeare uses this sexual catalog as a symbol, aiding him in his depiction of the play world as one in which lustful wants are openly expressed, and nearly impossible to hide. No matter where Pompey is, sexual desire will follow.
The fact that Pompey sees these men on death row suggests that the only way that Shakespeare's play world can eliminate lustful desire is by literally killing it off. By doing so, the play asserts its absolute authority over its characters (expressed through the characters Duke and Angelo). This absolute authority realizes that complete control is only gained by controlling all desires, sexual or otherwise, and that the only way to accomplish this goal is by destroying it. Consequently, the absolutism in the play is not only trying to control actions, but also abstract ideas.
Ultimately, this passage, as well as others in the play, are demonstrating how far a ruler has to go in order to gain complete dominion over their subjects IE the destruction of abstract ideas such as sexual desire. Shakespeare is questioning this absolutism, essentially wondering if the elimination of ideas is within the scope of any ruling power.

Thomas Marren
Amanda Waldo
Section 1A

Duke-What were you thinking?! Marriage Proposal

Measure For Measure
Act 5. Scene 1

Two attempts by the Duke:

Attempt #1:
Duke: [to Isabella] If he be like your brother, for his sake
Is pardoned; and for your lovely sake
Give me your hand, and say you will be mine.

Attempt #2:
Duke: Dear Isabel,
I have a motion (proposal) much imports your good,
Whereto, if you'll a willing ear incline,
What's mine is yours, and what yours is mine.

-As we discussed in class and according to our footnote: It is not clear how Isabella responds to the Duke's proposal of marriage.

What do you think?
*If Shakespeare had written Act 6-where would that take the play?

Danielle Moyer
Discussion 1C- Aaron Gorelik

THE ERA OF DISILLUSIONMENT

The Era of Disillusionment
Professor Little pointed out that with the passing of the golden Queen Elizabeth I (“I am the mother of this country and its subjects my children”) and the following ascension of the absolutist James I (“I am God on Earth”) to the throne of England, there is a clear shift in the tonality of Shakespeare’s plays – away from the light & comedic and towards the dark & complex.
Woven into the individual plots and themes of each of the later plays is now an ever-present examination of Disillusionment and Professor Little suggested that this all-embracing theme of Shakespeare’s Jacobean production can be seen as a sort of headline for the later plays, and in this way Disillusionment is the thematic root from which several interpretive variations may spring.
Professor Little went on to show how in Macbeth, Lady Macbeth’s Illusion that she is in control of her sex, her womanhood, her menstrual cycle as expressed in Act 1, scene 5 where she conjures her sexual powers – “make thick my blood/Stop up th’access and passage to remorse” – is dashed at the end of the play where the blood on her hands that can’t be washed away and keeps coming back is her own blood, her menstrual blood, the woman in her that cannot be killed.
Likewise, Macbeth’s Illusion – that as a god-like, invincible King his powers are eternal as long as he diligently crushes any threat to his masculine authoritarianism – is pointedly exposed as a very mortal human, almost laughable misinterpretation of fairy words, when at the end of the play Macbeth’s army is beaten by “the Great Birnam Wood” and he dies at the hand of a man who was “not of woman born.”

Susanne Wejp-Olsen, section 1E

1517: Martin Luther Nails the 95 Theses in Wittenberg

• 1517: Martin Luther Nailed the 95 Theses in Wittenberg
Martin Luther was attempting to catch the attention of the Pope and realized the way of doing so would be by nailing all of his complaints to the church door. Luther was then kicked out of the Catholic Church; subsequently establishing the foundation of Protestantism and further emphasizing his disapproval for Catholicism and its beliefs.

• With Catholicism the highest authority was the Pope, which was taught of as having two bodies: an earthly one and a spiritual one. The spiritual body was perfect in the sense that it was the representative of God. Catholics believed in the world of spirituality so when Christ left the physical body, earth, the idea of miracles/magic did not go away, which explains and allows for the existence of saints. Catholics had a profound belief in purgatory because for them an individual either went to heaven or hell; however, for the most part people would end up in purgatory until their dues were paid. While in purgatory Catholics had to give an extensive amount of money to the Church in order for the priest to pray for their passing relative, and it wasn’t until the priest decided you had given enough money to pay for his prayers, that your relative could then move from purgatory into heaven.

• Protestants decided to completely abolish the idea of purgatory. In Hamlet for example, Hamlet dies in this world of Catholicism, but he’s then stuck in a world without a purgatory because now all of a sudden people stopped believing in it. The way people mourned and think of the dead was inevitably affected because it left a sense of a pedestrian culture as it moved away from a world of “magical thinking,” thus the earth they were left with was a world in which magic/miracles become dead entities.

Janet Ruiz
Discussion 1D: Amanda Waldo

Racism in Othello

(This post was posted twice because I forgot to sign my name and section)


The racism in Othello also struck me, and more specifically in line 90 of act 1 scene 1:

"Even now, now, very now, and old black ram
is tupping your white ewe."

Refering to Othello as a ram suggests that the opinion of having sexual relations with a black man can be likened to sexing an animal, and also copulating with a satanic figure since the ram is associated with the devil. These facts lend themselves to the overall atmosphere of the play as being flipped and out of sync. Not only is a black men in line of receiving power by marrying a white women who is in power, but the marriage has occured before the start of the play to throw the play into chaos from the onset.

Jose "ABEL" Gonzalez
section 1E

Wednesday, October 22, 2008

Interrogatives? In Macbeth? Spells out Toil and Trouble

As Professor Little pointed out in class, the first four scenes of Macbeth begin with questions. These interrogatives let the read know that something is seriously wrong. The characters themselves don’t know what’s going on, which spells out panic and chaos for the rest of the play.

King Duncan particularly is introduced as a character by asking questions about his own battle. This emphasizes Duncan’s effeminate nature in Macbeth’s masculine society and establishes a weakness in what is supposed to be King Duncan’s supposed “rule of absolute authority” (a nod to King James I and his doctrine). How can a king rule absolutely if he doesn’t even know what’s going on in his kingdom?

The play opening interrogative mode, combined with other elements like bad weather and dodgy politics spell out to the reader though the first few scenes that the world of Macbeth is unstable and in a panic mode.

-Michelle Gonzalez

The Father and Authority in Measure for Measure

Coming to Measure for Measure right off the heels of Othello, one of the first things I looked at was marriages. Remember how in Othello, marriage and consummation occurred before the beginning of the play. Othello, in that case was described as a beginning in a state of disarray, then resuming the status quo through destruction. In Measure for Measure I see something similar occurring, the play starting in a state of disarray through the perversion of marriage and comedic conventions, but the solution is to superimpose a 'happy' comedic ending, rather than ending in tragedy.

Marriages in Shakespeare's era always went through a certain sequence, Father giving permission, Marriage then Consummation. However in Measure for Measure, this doesn't quite occur in this order. Consummation occurs before marriage, and the marriages at the end aren't conclusive or particularly joyous occasions. We have already covered sex in the lectures, so I will focus my post on the first in the sequence, the need to attain permission from the father.

First of all, there is no father in the play. While in Othello, this was highlighted as the major breach of decorum, in Measure for Measure, this is more subtle, being simply not mentioned. As far as the events in the play have occurred Juliet, Isabella and Mariana's father was not asked to consent to their marriages. In fact the 'father' of these families is not even present in the play. If we decide to look at father as just being the partriarchal figure of the society, then perhaps we can choose the Duke. But right at the beginning we see he, the head of this society, or our closest alternative to this 'father figure' steps down, and relinquishes the power of decision making. We then see that marriages do not occur, and in fact are forbidden during the next few Acts without patriarchal consent. Angelo, as an unsatisfactory replacement simply prevents marriages from occurring.

Marriages only occur right at the end, when the Duke regains his position and arranges the marriages. However, while this is preferable to the period before without this process, the marriages in the end still do not feel quite right. This can be attributed to the fact that, troublingly, the Duke usurps the role of the father. I probably sound rather freudian at the moment, but while the Duke in a way can be seen as the figurative father of the society, he is not the Isabella, Juliet, Mariana or indeed the whore that Lucio marries' true father. Thus, in a correctly functioning society he should not be able to authorise marriages for them. What occurs in the end is a show of authoritarian power, the Duke imposes his authority, bypassing the natural order and takes control of the family unit.

In the context of Shakespeare's time it is easy to draw parallels between the play and events occurring. The Duke's assumption of authoritarian power, usurping even the father's right's as head of the family can be seen as a direct response to James I's interest in authoritarianism. the contrast between Angelo's unsuitable rule, and the Duke's conclusive reassertion of power could also be an interesting comparison between the fears of authoritarianism against the fear of lacking a king altogether, that was acutely felt during the end of Elizabeth's reign. In fact it almost seems as if Shakespeare's predicting Oliver Cromwell, but I'm straying off topic. There is a fear perhaps, of how although peace can be obtained through authoritarian rule, this might not always be a satisfactory peace. And the dangers of authoritarianism intruding on previously sacred tenets, such as the fathers right to control his family, can be seen acutely expressed in this play.

This is part of the reason that the ending to Measure for Measure seems inconclusive, despite the marriages seeming, on the surface, to satisfy the requirements for a joyous ending. The effect of an authoritarian imposition of a comedic ending can be seen in fact that two of the marriages are enforced as punishments. Angelo marrying Mariana, and Lucio marrying a whore were both used as punishments with Lucio indeed claiming 'marrying a punk, my lord, is pressing to death, whipping, and hanging'(V.i.515-516). Isabella's marriage is alike, simply announced by the Duke, neglecting to ask the opinion of either Isabella, or more importantly, her father. The Duke simply is unable to provide conclusive happy marriages through his power. That is because he is trying to perform a role that he is not meant to play.

The Duke's assumption of patriarchal authority is one of the things that create the troubled ending, preventing it from fitting neatly into the comedy genre. The ending itself is one superimposed by Shakespeare, on the far more tragic ending of the original source text. In a sense you see Shakespeare using the Duke in a similar way. (except of course, since Shakespeare, if you will, is the 'God' of the universe he created, by having the Duke also doing the same thing he is, he is in fact having the Duke attain authority he is not meant to have). The Duke is superimposing the marriages of comedy onto a situation that should be tragic. So all in all, in the Duke's appropriation of Fatherly Authority, we see him transcending the limits of his own rank in part creating the uneasiness of the ending.

Quincy Chuck English 142B - Section 1F 22/10/2008